top of page

Why Rescue Matters: The story of one very lucky cat

Nov 5
4 min read

I received a text from an adopter today. She reached out to let me know that the cat she adopted from us many years ago had passed away. She was heartbroken but also knew it was his time.


I smiled as I remembered this cat very well. Both the cat and the adopter hold a special place in my heart, even more so because this cat had a history with the rescue.


This cat first came to us as a tiny kitten with his littermates. They were far too young to be removed from their mother, but the person who found them thought they had been abandoned.


The rescue quickly took action. We assessed the litter, got the kittens warmed up and fed, and attempted to locate their momma cat. Unfortunately, momma was gone.


None of his littermates made it, but we nursed him back to health. Because he was the only survivor and had such a rough start, we christened him “Lucky.” We got him vaccinated, neutered, and adopted out. Happy ending, right?


Most of the time, that’s the last we see or hear of an animal unless adopters send us a picture, stop by to visit, or occasionally send an email or letter letting us know their beloved pet has passed away.


But this cat’s journey was different. He had been adopted and had lived the first few years of his life with an adopter as an only pet. Then, unexpectedly, his adopter passed away. With no one to take him in, he came back to the rescue. As an adult and an all-black cat, finding a new home could be a challenge. But as luck would have it, we found his new forever home quickly.


Fast-forward eight years, and life threw yet another curveball. His second adopters, a mother and her young son, had fallen on hard times. It was during COVID, and the mother lost her job. She did everything she could, but eventually, she lost her home. Family members from out of state were willing to take her and her son in, but they had pets of their own. It wasn’t possible to bring another animal into an already overcrowded situation.


The son, who was now a young man, stood staring down at the floor, fighting back tears as they came in to surrender him. I remember trying to comfort them.


The mother wanted me to let her know who adopted Lucky. I explained that, for privacy reasons, I couldn’t share that information, but I would keep in touch. For years, the mother would reach out and ask how things were going. There was never any doubt that they loved that cat. It didn’t seem fair, but they did the right thing.


As we had the two times before, the rescue immediately began working to find Lucky a new home. But this time, he was a senior, all-black cat who still wasn’t used to other pets. The odds were stacked against him. We posted on social media, advertised in the local paper, and took him to every adoption event. Days turned into weeks. Not one application came through. I also noticed that he seemed to be shutting down. Maybe his luck was running out?


Then an application came in from a young woman who specifically wanted an older cat. She had grown up with pets but had not yet owned one on her own.


The rescue works hard to place animals with the right person or family. We make a commitment every time to ensure that the home an animal goes to is a good fit. Lucky’s new adopter needed to understand what he had been through. He would need patience and lots of love.


The applicant was super excited when we set up the meet-and-greet. For his part, Lucky just sat there. He didn’t move toward her or seem even remotely interested when she walked up to him. He stared into space as she petted him.


She asked a bunch of questions and then asked if she could have a few days to think about it. We didn’t have any other applications. What would it hurt?


A few days passed, but we didn’t hear from her. No other applications came in, either. Maybe she had changed her mind?


I told Lucky that, no matter what, he would always have a home with us. But because he didn’t get along with the other animals we had at the time, we kept him in a bedroom by himself. I spent as much time with him as I could. He continued to stare out the window.


Then we got a surprise! The applicant reached out and asked if Lucky was still available. She said she just wanted to make sure the things she had purchased were suitable for a senior cat. She also had a question: Would it be okay to rename him?


She understood that he had had that name for most of his life, but wouldn’t it be more appropriate to give him a new name to go along with this new chapter in his life? I agreed that it was a great idea!


So, not only did his luck change, but so did his name. He had a new name to go with his new life. And what a life it was! The third time really was a charm! He had finally found his forever home. He came out of his shell and lived out his golden years as a very spoiled, very loved pet. He was so happy and content that he even accepted another cat.


If he had not been found and rescued, just think what his life might have been like. If the rescue had not been able to take him back each time, who knows where he might have ended up?


Rescue work is an ongoing, never-ending mission. It takes all of us—volunteers and donors—to keep it going. And in Lucky’s case, it helped see him through to a long, happy life!

A special thank-you to former P.A.W.S. Board President Renee Schmidt for sharing Lucky’s touching adoption story and reminding us why rescue work matters so much. Every animal deserves a chance at a happy ending, no matter how many twists and turns their journey may take.

Comments


Best Non-Profit.jpeg

1224 W. Main Street, Greenfield, IN 46140

Click to Email Us

BOHC_Logo_2025.png
bottom of page